Research

They Might Be Giants, and the Self-Correcting Nature of Science

As has been widely observed, the number of retractions seen for scientific papers is on the rise. As Retraction Watch’s Ivan Oransky notes, this is “a good thing”. Aside from the obvious benefit of decreasing fraud, science is a process, and new discoveries correct previous results.

In that spirit, it’s worth noting that the always enjoyable band They Might Be Giants issued a retraction notice of their own. Back in 1993, they recorded Why Does the Sun Shine? (The Sun Is a Mass of Incandescent Gas) a cover of an obscure 1959 song based on the 1951 Golden Guide book “Stars”.

It turns out that 1951’s understanding of how the sun works wasn’t all that accurate, so in 2009, the band recorded and released Why Does the Sun Really Shine? (The Sun is a Miasma of Incandescent Plasma) for their superb children’s album, Here Comes Science. If only all retraction notices were this catchy…

About David Crotty

I am a Senior Editor with Oxford University Press' journal publishing program. Prior to that I served as an Executive Editor at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, and was also the commissioning editor for their book publishing program. Many years ago, I was a research scientist, receiving my Ph.D. in Genetics & Development from Columbia University, and doing postdoctoral research in neural development at Caltech.

Discussion

One thought on “They Might Be Giants, and the Self-Correcting Nature of Science

  1. “They” also have a great song about quantum science and it’s impact on humanity (“Particle Man”, circa 1989?), for which they have offered no such retraction…I guess, considering the ever-changing perspective on atomic/subatomic physics, that song would warrant retractions and corrections on (at least) an annual basis, which would be impractical. Then again, if one listens to this song carefully, it will be noted that They have cleverly composed their description of the quantum character in the form of questions, and so they are off the hook for accountability…In fact, the very nature of the playfully personified entity, “Particle Man”, is dismissed as wholly unimportant; perhaps this is further evidence that They were cognizant of the potential for missteps when commenting, even in an artistic sense, on highly theoretical concepts and so composed the lyrics in a manner to avoid controversy (probably as a result of the hub-bub arising from Their gaff with the Sun song….or was that recorded later?)

    Posted by marklewisgoodwin | Aug 2, 2013, 10:17 am

Side Dishes by Stewart Wills

Find Posts by Category

Find Posts by Date

August 2013
S M T W T F S
« Jul   Sep »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

The Scholarly Kitchen on Twitter

SSP_LOGO
The mission of the Society for Scholarly Publishing (SSP) is "[t]o advance scholarly publishing and communication, and the professional development of its members through education, collaboration, and networking." SSP established The Scholarly Kitchen blog in February 2008 to keep SSP members and interested parties aware of new developments in publishing.
......................................
The Scholarly Kitchen is a moderated and independent blog. Opinions on The Scholarly Kitchen are those of the authors. They are not necessarily those held by the Society for Scholarly Publishing nor by their respective employers.
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 14,426 other followers

%d bloggers like this: